Top Ten Pound-for-Pound Mixed Martial Arts Fighters
I know there's going to be some disagreement here, but this is my personal list of who I believe to be the top ten pound-for-pound MMA fighters in the world. Certainly there's more consensus for some guys who didn't make my list, but I like any true MMA fan, should be judging talent based on my own two eyes rather than analytical consensus. With the MMA's growing presence and legitimacy in the sports realm, and the caliber of established and prospective talent across the three major MMA associations (UFC, Bellator, Strikeforce), there's an immensely bright future for the sport. Their wilingness to gather talent and continuously put the best fighters up against the best fighters has legitimized MMA as a mainstay of Pay-Per-View excitement. I'd even go as far as to say that MMA could eventually become one of the top 4 most popular sports in the country, if it's not already.
Honorable Mention: Carlos Condit
Ground and Pound. That's what comes to mind for me with me when talking about interim welterweight champion Carlos Condit. Like many of the top fighters in the lighter weight classes Condit is a great striker, but he's certainly not beholden to it. While his striking is dangerous, Condit likes to use long kicks and more ranged attacks in order daze his opponent to the mat, where he just absolutely destroys people. He may be one of the best ground and pound fighters in the sport, and seldom leaves opponents any breathing room on the mat. His ability to get guys down and switch from striking to grappling in a heartbeat has him on the verge of my top ten list. If he wants to stay there though, he's gonna have to prove he can avoid being completely dismantled by the former champ George St. Pierre. I know, MMA fans are screaming "Gilbert Melendez!!". Still a bit too soon for me on that one, but Condit is proven.
10. Cain Velasquez

9. Dan "Hendo" Henderson

While losing to Benson Henderson by unanimous decision his last go, Frankie Edgar has all the tools to return to championship gold. His versatility is his best quality, and he's proved it with wins against quality competition like BJ Penn and Gray Maynard. It's only fair that he get his rematch with Ben Henderson after continuously proving why he was a title holder. I don't think he'll beat Henderson in the rematch just because Henderson is so incredibly gifted athletically, but the lightweight division is dripping with talent, and you've got to give anybody who holds that lightweight title a lot of credit.
It's really incredible to me how Dominick Cruz doesn't get hit more than he does, because he hardly gets hit at all. He's so quick he can bob and weave so well it can make good fighters feel look like idiots. That said, he has a tendency to rely on long range hooks that can often miss the target. For most fighters that would be a great recipe to leave yourself defenseless but somehow he manages to avoid overcommitting on any them, and can maintain his balance to keep his guard up. He makes himself even harder to counter by following those hooks with great combination sequences that can carry some force. If there's one guy who has been able to get at his chin, it's Urijah Faber, unfortunately Cruz tore his ACL in preparation for their July 7th tiebreaker at UFC 148, so we might have to wait a while to see him back in action.
6. Benson "Smooth" Henderson

5. Junior "Cigano" Dos Santos
I'm sorry, I just can't have any respect for any top ten pound-for-pound list that doesn't have Junior Dos Santos on it. Cigano is on another stratosphere from any other heavyweight not named Cain Velasquez, certainly not until Alistair Overeem can prove that he can still be a great fighter when he doesn't have 10 times the normal level of testosterone in his body. He might be the most versatile heavyweight to ever grace the sport. When a guy that athletic has no technical weaknesses to speak of, you know you got a freak of a fighter. His boxing skills are as polished as anybody in MMA, but he forces you to deal with it because his takedown defense is impeccable. You're not going get Dos Santos on the ground often, but if you do, it'll likely be after one of his powerful yet precise punches smash your face and he goes to the mat to finish you off.
4. Jose "Junior" Aldo

3. George "Rush" St. Pierre
I should be very clear about this: the only reason I don't have GSP higher right now is because there's no telling whether or not he's going to come back as the same guy after ripping up his ACL. It won't be any picnic either, he's got a very formidable opponent in Carlos Condit waiting for him when he gets back. I fully expect GSP to tear out Condit's heart and feed it to him, but until I see it happen, I'll have to reserve my judgement. GSP may be my favorite fighter of all time, but in recent fights he has been criticized for not being able to finish his opponents off. I'm not going there. GSP is way too precise for me to question the guy's knockout ability. In my opinion St. Pierre is the most precise fighter in the history of MMA, and I don't care who you want to put up there against him. It's not limited to just his striking ability either, he always knows the right move for the particular situation and his execution is virtually flawless. When he wants a takedown, he's going to get one, and when he gets one fighters usually end up in more trouble than they can handle.
2. Jon "Bones" Jones
Might be the best young talent in MMA history, and quite possibly the most athletically gifted fighter in the sport today. The guy's so good it's hard at this point to tell if he even has all the tools that the most versatile fighters in the business have because he hasn't been forced to use them yet. Few people can instinctively strike with the type of vicious, unpredictability that Jones displays, but his game clearly goes farther than just being able to beat a guy senseless. He's just too fast, too strong, and most importantly too damn creative to be stopped right now. Powerful enough to pick up the big boys and slam them yet quick enough to barrage them with combination uppercuts and knees, Jon Jones could make the prime of Roy Jones Jr's career look like one of those movie prequels where the protagonist is still trying to find himself. Don't be the least bit shocked if Jones becomes the consensus pound-for-pound fighter the second Anderson Silva calls it a career, or Chael Sonnen beats Silva in a rematch.
1. Anderson "The Spider" Silva
